« Both Sides of Time by Caroline B. Cooney | Main | Leap Frogging the Action »

01/19/2012

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Debbie Heal

Let me begin by saying this is pretty exciting stuff. It makes me want to know more about the story. So that right off is a tremendous accomplishment.

I think there is a point of view glitch, Miss Anonymous. When you say "I failed to realized, however, that I had only two options." you are stepping outside of yourself to make the sort of comment a 3rd person narrator would make. After all, if you don't realize your options, how can you then tell us what they are? But that's easily fixed.

Now let's hear responses from anyone out there reading this blog. Please join in by clicking the comment button.

Now

Barbara Woods

I fully agree that it is exciting and makes me want to read more. I do feel that there are a couple of places where it would have been better to use a more common word rather than the word used. Also saw a few typos but that is easily fixed. Personally I am not into fantasy however I think I would enjoy this book.

Debbie Heal

The fact that no one has commented is not an indication of lack of interest in your writing. It's either blog shyness or they just aren't coming to my blog in the first place. Sigh.

Miss Anonymous

I am happy to have had even the two of you read and critique my work. I am extremely excited to hear that you both found my story captivating--and that you're interested in learning more about it. It's not your everyday fantasy. In reality, parts of the story will be quite dark. But in my opinion, the dark pieces only make the brighter moments seem brighter! I have a huge interest in human relationships, so I focus a lot of attention on how the characters feel and react to one another. I also use a lot of details. I COMPLETELY understand where you're coming from, Barbara, when you said to possibly use a more common word, rather than using an unusual one. Sometimes I feel as though my vocabulary is a little strong given that my main character (and basically narrator) is a 17 year old girl! As far as the typos go, I suspected that there would be some. This is only my 2nd draft. I plan to go back and edit once I've made it through the book again. I tend to type INCREDIBLY fast when I'm writing the story(mostly because I come up with many of my ideas as I'm writing them). I have trouble keeping up with myself sometimes because I don't want to lose my flow! But, I promise that I'll work on that a little better. My worst habit, as far as writing goes, would have to be the dialogue format. For example...

I will do this:
"Help me." She called out. "It's got me!"

When I SHOULD be typing this:
"Help me," she called out, "it's got me!"

The funny thing is that I TOTALLY understand that I should be typing it that way, but it's a force of habit. And, like I said before, I usually don't worry about formalities and/or perfecting my grammar until later--so as not to disrupt the flow! If anyone would be interested in reading and critiquing some more, feel free to contact me through Debbie! I would GREATLY appreciate any sort of feedback and/or help that I can get! Thank you so much for already supporting me and commenting!

Ron Pugsley

Reading this small exert from the story makes me want to read the rest of the story, and I know that reading this small portion wasn't a waste of time. I have read stories in the past that made me feel like I am wasting my time, and I was only reading them to pass time. I can tell from this small portion that this is not one of those stories.

Sense of adventure, nice wording and great imagery makes me want to read more of the story. If you can accomplish to actually pull a reader into the story, you have accomplished attracting their full attention, making them want more and more. I have a feeling this story does that. Great job, Miss Anonymous.

Laura Johnson

Brilliant! Captivating from start to finish. Would like to read entire story. Thankyou for sharing.

Kyle Shultz

Very nice lead-in, and from the start to its finish, Miss Anonymous wants you to want more. She does a great job at describing her layout in the scenery, and it paints a great picture for the reader to give this sense of adventure a breath of life. Despite a few hit or miss spots with some words and/or dialogue, it is really good and an enjoyable read. We also have to take in that you said this is only the 2nd draft, so we have to expect a typo or two. Can't wait to read more. Excellent job, Miss Anonymous.

Debbie Heal

Miss Anonymous, I am so with you on the letting it flow thing. I always tell anyone who asks that a writer should not shut down the creative right side of his/her brain by worrying about editing when they are letting the story rip. Time enough for that later.

Debbie Heal

By the way, welcome to the blog, you commentators of Miss Anonymous. Please feel free to browse some of the other topics and comment away.

Miss Anonymous

Thank you all SO MUCH for your kind words. It's definitely hard to stay dedicated to something whenever the only feedback you've had is your own. It often gets me thinking that perhaps my story isn't as good as I think it is and that people will not want to read it. But then I realize just how much the story and characters mean to me...and I write it anyway! In fact, I tend to write a LOT. I was sharing with Debbie that I actually type upwards of 9500 words per chapter. That's made my average chapter around 34-36 pages--some have even been longer. As I said, this is the second copy of my book. The first copy concluded at 17 chapters (and about 450 pages). Going by my increase on length this time through (and given that I'm currently finishing up chapter 10) I realize that this copy will probably go a little past 17 chapters. BUT, if it doesn't, we're looking at around 600+ pages for book one. How about that? It really makes sense to me now why it's taking so long whenever I don't have to come up with the story! :) But, as I've said a MILLION times...all good things take time--and I want my readers to see the story as amazing, just like I do. Anything in particular stand out to anyone about this exert as far as the story goes? What particularly draws your attention?

Debbie Heal

You know what the really good part is? All that love for your characters and plot will pay off in more than one way--not only a good book someday, but invaluable writing experience forever. Writing an actual story is so much better practice than just journaling.

Debbie Heal

Miss Anonymous, please see the post about Leap Frogging. You might find this a helpful technique. I know I have. It's under the category "Good Writing." http://debbieheal.typepad.com/write-brain-activity/good-writing/

Your friendly neighborhood Spiderman

I loved the story, as an early reader of past and current editions, I must say I am immensely proud of the progress that you have achieved. As many have said there is a few problems with grammar or other simple problems, and as you know I have caught many typos before they have been given out. The difference between your original editions of this and your latest ones I have to say as well are simply astounding, I have to tell you, if this series doesn't become famous, readers will have missed out on one amazing piece of literature. I fully support everything you do, keep on writing and I will keep on reading, oohhh do I feel like such a book hipster!

Miss Anonymous

Spiderman, I do believe you have caught my attention. I will continue to send you my work as long as you swoop in and say a bunch of sappy, supportive stuff like that! Thanks a billion, friend.

Jacob D. Poettker

I really enjoy these types of books. This kept me interested from start to finish. I liked how you never called the red-haired girl by name, because it really shows the readers how new this character is to Madelyn. If i were to do differently about this, is let us really get to know Madelyn, describe how she's feeling. How do her choices and the events happening around her make her feel. You have events happening here, but we never really get to see how Madelyn reacts to this. Let us inside her and see how her mind is ticking. Over all, I very much enjoyed it and I would say that you have a natural writing talent. Good job!

Sam Hanson

Thank you so much, Jacob! It isn't showed much in this blurb, but I spend a LOT of time within the novel talking about her feelings. The reason I picked this particular blurb is because it's actually the first time that she isn't really thinking. She's just freaked because her world has been turned upside down before her eyes. She had just witnessed her friend's torture and almost death, as well as suffered herself. At this moment, she is basically trying to just survive and doesn't really have time to process that what once seemed IMPOSSIBLE was happening before her (i.e. the transfiguration, spell casting, flying, etc.) Does that make sense?

Jacob D. Poettker

It makes perfect sense. thank you for clearing that up!

Sam Hanson

Anytime! I have thought all of the scenarios and/or critiques through carefully! Yet, I stand by my work. Given that this is only the last 3 pages of Chapter 9, it's natural that nobody knows the whole story. Thus, I understand your confusion. If I was in your position and had only read what is above, I might feel the same way! Thank you SO MUCH everyone for your support! I am incredibly happy that I'm able to be reminded on a constant basis that I'm not wasting my time writing. It's good to have that extra boost of confidence that helps me push through those LONG chapters! I'll never forget any of it.

Megan Legenbass

I haven't read much in the realm of fantasy novels, but this is so intriguing! So much passion and talent is infused within these words. Even though I didn't know the story line before reading this, I found myself caring for Madelyn and the choices she had to make. The character seemed so real and raw. Great job Miss Anonymous!

Miss Anonymous

Thank you so much Miss Legenbass. I have tried very much to put as much reality into my novel as possible. I have spent COUNTLESS hours figuring out just who Madelyn is--and in turn, I've developed a main character that I adore, and I think others will adore, as well. Thank you so much for your kind words. They mean a lot.

stephen johnson

thourlghly enjoying. i want to read more..... only issue i have is the use of one or two turns of prhase. but that is just the oppinion of reader not an author

Emily

This is beautiful. It's natural and vivid while also reading like a true fantasy novel. I love it.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Most Recent Photos

  • Images
  • Small christian fish mosaic symbol
  • 13015938
  • Small version
  • IStock_000002552297small
  • Sribophile
  • Super-christian
  • Weaving
  • Historicalfiction
  • Christian-fiction-2
  • Im-not-listening
  • OddThomas